| | | Case Western Reserve wins the toss and defers. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr35 | CWR ball on CWR35. |
| | | Nick Bavaro kickoff 57 yards to the WAY8, Jaison Faulk return 16 yards to the WAY24 (Andrew Banathy). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way24 | Jake Forsythe rush for 1 yard to the WAY25 (Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 2-9 | at Way25 | Jake Forsythe rush for 7 yards to the WAY32 (Scott Suren). |
| Way | 3-2 | at Way32 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Zac Capan, dropped pass. |
| Way | 4-2 | at Way32 | Jonathan Hager punt 36 yards to the CWR32, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr32 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 13:31. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr32 | Anthony Bianco rush for loss of 2 yards to the CWR30 (JT Thompson;Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 2-12 | at Cwr30 | Billy Beecher pass complete to George Darany for 3 yards to the CWR33 (Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 3-9 | at Cwr33 | Billy Beecher rush for 8 yards to the CWR41, out-of-bounds. |
| Cwr | 4-1 | at Cwr41 | Canganelli punt 24 yards to the WAY35, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way35 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 11:38. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way35 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Zac Capan (Nick Kwon). |
| Way | 2-10 | at Way35 | Jake Forsythe rush for 17 yards to the CWR48, 1ST DOWN WAY (Scott Suren). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr48 | Carter Hill pass incomplete (Josh Rogers). |
| Way | 2-10 | at Cwr48 | Jake Forsythe rush for 1 yard to the CWR47 (Mike O'Donnell). |
| Way | 3-9 | at Cwr47 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Zac Capan. |
| Way | 4-9 | at Cwr47 | Jonathan Hager punt 33 yards to the CWR14, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr14 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 10:06. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr14 | Manny Sicre rush for 2 yards to the CWR16 (Josh Tolliver), PENALTY WAY personal foul (Josh Tolliver) 15 yards to the CWR31, 1ST DOWN CWR. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr31 | 1st and 10. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr31 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Ethan Albers for 7 yards to the CWR38. |
| Cwr | 2-3 | at Cwr38 | Manny Sicre rush for 2 yards to the CWR40. |
| Cwr | 3-1 | at Cwr40 | Anthony Bianco rush for 8 yards to the CWR48, 1ST DOWN CWR (Aaron Palmer;Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr48 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Bryan Erb for 7 yards to the WAY45 (Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 2-3 | at Way45 | Anthony Bianco rush for 1 yard to the WAY44 (Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 3-2 | at Way44 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Manny Sicre for 1 yard to the WAY43 (Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 4-1 | at Way43 | Manny Sicre rush for 1 yard to the WAY42, 1ST DOWN CWR (Kyle Richey). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way42 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to Brendan Lynch. |
| Cwr | 2-10 | at Way42 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Bryan Erb for 1 yard to the WAY41 (Danny Morgan;Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 3-9 | at Way41 | Billy Beecher sacked for loss of 7 yards to the WAY48 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 4-16 | at Way48 | Adrian Cannon punt 38 yards to the WAY10, Bernie Thompson return 8 yards to the WAY18 (Owen Williams). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 38 yards, TOP 04:59 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way18 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 05:07. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way18 | Jake Forsythe rush for 3 yards to the WAY21 (Josh Rogers). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Way21 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Andrew English. |
| Way | 3-7 | at Way21 | Jake Forsythe rush for loss of 2 yards to the WAY19 (Josh Rogers). |
| Way | 4-9 | at Way19 | Jonathan Hager punt 42 yards to the CWR39, Dan Cronin return 4 yards to the CWR43 (Jaison Faulk). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr43 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 03:34. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr43 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Adam Hochman for 4 yards to the CWR47 (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 2-6 | at Cwr47 | Canganelli rush for 7 yards to the WAY46, 1ST DOWN CWR (Aaron Palmer;John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way46 | Canganelli rush for 5 yards to the WAY41 (Kyle Richey). |
| Cwr | 2-5 | at Way41 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Sean Lapcevic for 6 yards to the WAY35, 1ST DOWN CWR (M. Lopuchovsky;Mitch Vacek). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way35 | Canganelli rush for 12 yards to the WAY23, 1ST DOWN CWR (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way23 | Canganelli rush for 3 yards to the WAY20 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 2-7 | at Way20 | Canganelli rush for loss of 3 yards to the WAY23 (John Sikora;Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 3-10 | at Way23 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to DiFrancesco. |
| Cwr | 4-10 | at Way23 | Nick Bavaro field goal attempt from 40 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 3, Waynesburg 0 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 34 yards, TOP 03:55 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 3, Waynesburg 0 |
| Cwr | 1-G | at Cwr35 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | Nick Bavaro kickoff 53 yards to the WAY12, Jaison Faulk return to the WAY22 (Jordan Esteban;Ethan Albers), PENALTY CWR offside 5 yards to the CWR30, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 34 yards, TOP 03:55 |
| | | Nick Bavaro kickoff 56 yards to the WAY14, Willie Leavell return 86 yards to the CWR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:39. |
| Way | 1-G | at Cwr03 | PENALTY WAY false start 5 yards to the CWR8. |
| | | Scott Lewis kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 7, Case Western Reserve 3 |
| Way | 1-G | at Way35 | WAY ball on WAY35. |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 42 yards to the CWR23, Ryan Berg return 7 yards to the CWR30 (Tyler Givens;Z. Sniadach). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 14:35. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 14:35. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Brendan Lynch for 11 yards to the CWR41, 1ST DOWN CWR (M. Lopuchovsky;Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr41 | Anthony Bianco rush for 3 yards to the CWR44 (Zach Machuga). |
| Cwr | 2-7 | at Cwr44 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Sean Lapcevic for 7 yards to the WAY49, 1ST DOWN CWR (Tyler Givens). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way49 | Anthony Bianco rush for loss of 3 yards to the CWR48 (JT Thompson). |
| Cwr | 2-13 | at Cwr48 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Brendan Lynch for 25 yards to the WAY27, 1ST DOWN CWR (Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way27 | Anthony Bianco rush for 2 yards to the WAY25 (Zach Machuga). |
| Cwr | 2-8 | at Way25 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete. |
| Cwr | 3-8 | at Way25 | Billy Beecher rush for 5 yards to the WAY20 (Zach Machuga;Jon. Carlier). |
| Cwr | 4-3 | at Way20 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Bryan Erb for 20 yards to the WAY0, 1ST DOWN CWR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:51. |
| | | Nick Bavaro kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Kyle Richey). |
| | | Case Western Reserve 9, Waynesburg 7 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 70 yards, TOP 03:44 |
| | | Nick Bavaro kickoff 29 yards to the WAY36, fair catch by Anthony Bruno. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way36 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 10:50. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way36 | Carter Hill pass complete to Willie Leavell for 9 yards to the WAY45 (Mike O'Donnell). |
| Way | 2-1 | at Way45 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Kevin Barnes, dropped pass. |
| Way | 3-1 | at Way45 | Willie Leavell rush for 2 yards to the WAY47, 1ST DOWN WAY (Gavin Sandidge;Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way47 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Bernie Thompson. |
| Way | 2-10 | at Way47 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 11 yards to the CWR42, 1ST DOWN WAY (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr42 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 5 yards to the CWR37, out-of-bounds (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 2-5 | at Cwr37 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 9 yards to the CWR28, 1ST DOWN WAY (Jordan Esteban). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr28 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for loss of 2 yards to the CWR30 (Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 2-12 | at Cwr30 | Jake Forsythe rush for 3 yards to the CWR27 (Josh Rogers;Zach Lyon). |
| Way | 3-9 | at Cwr27 | Carter Hill pass complete to Willie Leavell for 3 yards to the CWR24 (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 4-6 | at Cwr24 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 24 yards to the CWR0, 1ST DOWN WAY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:30. |
| | | Scott Lewis kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| Way | 1-G | at Way35 | PENALTY CWR personal foul 15 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 64 yards, TOP 04:20 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 50 yards to the CWR0, touchback. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 06:30. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | Canganelli rush for 17 yards to the CWR37, 1ST DOWN CWR (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr37 | Canganelli rush for 5 yards to the CWR42 (Tyler Givens). |
| Cwr | 2-5 | at Cwr42 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Adam Hochman for 10 yards to the WAY48, 1ST DOWN CWR (Z. Sniadach). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way48 | Canganelli rush for 3 yards to the WAY45 (JT Thompson). |
| Cwr | 2-7 | at Way45 | Billy Beecher pass complete to George Darany for 23 yards to the WAY22, 1ST DOWN CWR (Danny Morgan;Z. Sniadach). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way22 | Manny Sicre rush for no gain to the WAY22 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 2-10 | at Way22 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to Brendan Lynch (Danny Morgan). |
| Cwr | 3-10 | at Way22 | Billy Beecher rush for 4 yards to the WAY18 (Zach Machuga;Tyler Givens). |
| Cwr | 4-6 | at Way18 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 03:38. |
| Cwr | 4-6 | at Way18 | Billy Beecher pass intercepted by M. Lopuchovsky at the WAY8, M. Lopuchovsky return 42 yards to the 50 yardline (Billy Beecher). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 62 yards, TOP 03:04 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 03:26. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | Jake Forsythe rush for 5 yards to the CWR45 (Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 2-5 | at Cwr45 | Jake Forsythe rush for 6 yards to the CWR39, 1ST DOWN WAY (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr39 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Andrew English, PENALTY WAY holding (Nik Sappie) 10 yards to the CWR49, NO PLAY. |
| Way | 1-20 | at Cwr49 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to M. Lopuchovsky. |
| Way | 2-20 | at Cwr49 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 4 yards to the CWR45 (Gavin Sandidge). |
| Way | 3-16 | at Cwr45 | Carter Hill pass complete to Zac Capan for 13 yards to the CWR32, out-of-bounds (Mike O'Donnell), PENALTY WAY personal foul (Nik Sappie) 15 yards to the CWR47. |
| Way | 3-18 | at Cwr47 | 4th and 18. |
| Way | 4-18 | at Cwr47 | Jonathan Hager punt 47 yards to the CWR0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 01:39. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to Brendan Lynch. |
| Cwr | 2-10 | at Cwr20 | Canganelli rush for 3 yards to the CWR23 (Kyle Richey). |
| Cwr | 3-7 | at Cwr23 | Billy Beecher rush for 3 yards to the CWR26 (JT Thompson). |
| Cwr | 4-4 | at Cwr26 | Adrian Cannon punt 34 yards to the WAY40, Bernie Thompson return 6 yards to the WAY46 (KJ Pederson;Zach Lyon). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way46 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 00:38. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way46 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Zac Capan. |
| Way | 2-10 | at Way46 | Willie Leavell rush for 47 yards to the CWR7, 1ST DOWN WAY, out-of-bounds (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 1-G | at Cwr07 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 7 yards to the CWR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:19. |
| | | Scott Lewis kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 21, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 54 yards, TOP 00:19 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 56 yards to the CWR9, Brendan Lynch return 20 yards to the CWR29 (Drew Glotfelty). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr29 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 00:10. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr29 | Team rush for loss of 1 yard to the CWR28. |
| Cwr | 2-11 | at Cwr28 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | Waynesburg 21, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| Cwr | 2-11 | at Cwr28 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Cwr | 2-11 | at Cwr28 | WAY ball on WAY35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 47 yards to the CWR18, Brendan Lynch return 12 yards to the CWR30 (Ian Biernacki). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 14:55. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | Canganelli rush for 1 yard to the CWR31 (JT Thompson;Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 2-9 | at Cwr31 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Sean Lapcevic for 4 yards to the CWR35 (John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 3-5 | at Cwr35 | Billy Beecher pass complete to George Darany for 11 yards to the CWR46, 1ST DOWN CWR (Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr46 | Billy Beecher rush for 16 yards to the WAY38, 1ST DOWN CWR (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way38 | Canganelli rush for 2 yards to the WAY36 (John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 2-8 | at Way36 | Canganelli rush for 8 yards to the WAY28, 1ST DOWN CWR (Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way28 | Canganelli rush for 8 yards to the WAY20 (Mitch Vacek;M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 2-2 | at Way20 | Canganelli rush for no gain to the WAY20 (Kyle Richey;JT Thompson). |
| Cwr | 3-2 | at Way20 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Adam Hochman for loss of 1 yard to the WAY21 (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Cwr | 4-3 | at Way21 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Adam Hochman for 1 yard to the WAY20. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 50 yards, TOP 04:51 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way20 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 10:04. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way20 | Carter Hill pass complete to Willie Leavell for 3 yards to the WAY23 (Ryan Berg). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Way23 | Jake Forsythe rush for loss of 2 yards to the WAY21 (Dayton Snyder). |
| Way | 3-9 | at Way21 | PENALTY WAY delay of game (Carter Hill) 5 yards to the WAY16. |
| Way | 3-14 | at Way16 | Willie Leavell rush for 13 yards to the WAY29 (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 4-1 | at Way29 | Jonathan Hager punt 39 yards to the CWR32, Dan Cronin return 12 yards to the CWR44 (Danny Morgan). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:17 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr44 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 07:47. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr44 | Billy Beecher rush for 4 yards to the CWR48, fumble forced by Josh Tolliver, fumble by Billy Beecher recovered by WAY Dontae Gibson at WAY46. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:08 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way46 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 07:39. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way46 | Jake Forsythe rush for 1 yard to the WAY47 (Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 2-9 | at Way47 | Carter Hill rush for 24 yards to the CWR29, 1ST DOWN WAY (Scott Suren), PENALTY WAY personal foul (Willie Leavell) 15 yards to the CWR44. |
| Way | 1-25 | at Cwr44 | 1st and 10. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr44 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 22 yards to the CWR22, 1ST DOWN WAY (Aaron Weisberg;Tyler Doty). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr22 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 22 yards to the CWR0, 1ST DOWN WAY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:56. |
| | | Scott Lewis kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 28, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 54 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 48 yards to the CWR17, Brendan Lynch return 14 yards to the CWR31 (Jon. Carlier). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr31 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 05:51. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr31 | Billy Beecher pass complete to DiFrancesco for 5 yards to the CWR36 (Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 2-5 | at Cwr36 | Canganelli rush for 1 yard to the CWR37 (Zach Machuga). |
| Cwr | 3-4 | at Cwr37 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Manny Sicre for loss of 1 yard to the CWR36 (Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 4-5 | at Cwr36 | Adam Hochman rush for 25 yards to the WAY39, 1ST DOWN CWR (Bernie Thompson). |
| | | Fake Punt |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way39 | PENALTY CWR substitution infraction 5 yards to the WAY44. |
| Cwr | 1-15 | at Way44 | Manny Sicre rush for 2 yards to the WAY42 (Zach Machuga). |
| Cwr | 2-13 | at Way42 | Billy Beecher pass complete to Brendan Lynch for 5 yards to the WAY37 (Jordan Voitus). |
| Cwr | 3-8 | at Way37 | Billy Beecher pass complete to George Darany for 5 yards to the WAY32, out-of-bounds (John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 4-3 | at Way32 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to DiFrancesco (Dontae Gibson). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 37 yards, TOP 04:12 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way32 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 01:39. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way32 | Jake Forsythe rush for 3 yards to the WAY35 (Gavin Sandidge;Ryan Berg). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Way35 | Jake Forsythe rush for 6 yards to the WAY41 (Nick Kwon). |
| Way | 3-1 | at Way41 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 00:42. |
| Way | 3-1 | at Way41 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake DiGuilio for 10 yards to the CWR49, 1ST DOWN WAY (Mike O'Donnell). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr49 | Jake Forsythe rush for 4 yards to the CWR45 (Tyler Doty). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 23 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| | | Waynesburg 28, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| Way | 2-6 | at Cwr45 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Way | 2-6 | at Cwr45 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 23 yards to the CWR22 (Mike O'Donnell), PENALTY WAY ineligible downfield on pass 5 yards to the 50 yardline, NO PLAY. |
| Way | 2-11 | at Way50 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Andrew English. |
| Way | 3-11 | at Way50 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Kevin Barnes. |
| Way | 4-11 | at Way50 | Jonathan Hager punt 39 yards to the CWR11, Dan Cronin return 13 yards to the CWR24 (Justin Layton). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr24 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 14:10. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr24 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to Bryan Erb (Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 2-10 | at Cwr24 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to Bryan Erb. |
| Cwr | 3-10 | at Cwr24 | Billy Beecher sacked for loss of 3 yards to the CWR21 (JT Thompson). |
| Cwr | 4-13 | at Cwr21 | Adrian Cannon punt 37 yards to the WAY42, Bernie Thompson return 8 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds (Tim Briercheck). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 13:12. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | Jake Forsythe rush for loss of 4 yards to the WAY46 (Dayton Snyder). |
| Way | 2-14 | at Way46 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 5 yards to the CWR49 (Jordan Esteban), PENALTY WAY holding (Andrew English) 10 yards to the WAY41. |
| Way | 2-19 | at Way41 | 2nd and 19. |
| Way | 2-19 | at Way41 | Jake Forsythe rush for 7 yards to the WAY48 (KJ Pederson). |
| Way | 3-12 | at Way48 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 13 yards to the CWR39, 1ST DOWN WAY, out-of-bounds (Aaron Weisberg;Ryan Berg). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr39 | Jake Forsythe rush for 2 yards to the CWR37 (Dayton Snyder). |
| Way | 2-8 | at Cwr37 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Andrew English (Owen Williams). |
| Way | 3-8 | at Cwr37 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 10:24. |
| Way | 3-8 | at Cwr37 | Carter Hill sacked for loss of 5 yards to the CWR42 (Josh Rogers;Dayton Snyder). |
| Way | 4-13 | at Cwr42 | Jonathan Hager punt 42 yards to the CWR0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 8 yards, TOP 03:41 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 09:31. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr20 | Adam Hochman rush for 9 yards to the CWR29 (Kyle Richey). |
| Cwr | 2-1 | at Cwr29 | Adam Hochman rush for no gain to the CWR29. |
| Cwr | 3-1 | at Cwr29 | Billy Beecher pass incomplete to George Darany. |
| Cwr | 4-1 | at Cwr29 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 08:35. |
| Cwr | 4-1 | at Cwr29 | Billy Beecher sacked for loss of 10 yards to the CWR19 (John Sikora). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:02 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr19 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 08:29. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Cwr19 | Jake Forsythe rush for 8 yards to the CWR11 (Cody Calhoun;Nick Kwon). |
| Way | 2-2 | at Cwr11 | Jake Forsythe rush for 6 yards to the CWR5, 1ST DOWN WAY (Aaron Weisberg). |
| Way | 1-G | at Cwr05 | Jake Forsythe rush for no gain to the CWR5 (Gavin Sandidge;Aaron Weisberg), PENALTY WAY illegal block 10 yards to the CWR15, NO PLAY. |
| Way | 1-G | at Cwr15 | Carter Hill pass complete to Zac Capan for 15 yards to the CWR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:59. |
| | | Scott Lewis kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 35, Case Western Reserve 9 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 54 yards to the CWR11, Brendan Lynch return to the CWR13 (Tym Burkholder), PENALTY WAY offside 5 yards to the WAY30, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 19 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| | | Scott Lewis kickoff 59 yards to the CWR11, Brendan Lynch return 19 yards to the CWR30 (Tyler Givens). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 06:45. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr30 | Adam Hochman rush for 3 yards to the CWR33 (Adam Steiner). |
| Cwr | 2-7 | at Cwr33 | Canganelli rush for 5 yards to the CWR38 (Mike Martin). |
| Cwr | 3-2 | at Cwr38 | Canganelli rush for no gain to the CWR38 (Aaron Palmer). |
| Cwr | 4-2 | at Cwr38 | Connor Simpson pass complete to Brendan Lynch for 6 yards to the CWR44, 1ST DOWN CWR (Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr44 | Canganelli rush for 5 yards to the CWR49 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Cwr | 2-5 | at Cwr49 | Connor Simpson pass complete to DiFrancesco for 9 yards to the WAY42, 1ST DOWN CWR (Josh Mundell). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way42 | Rob Cuda rush for 7 yards to the WAY35 (John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 2-3 | at Way35 | Connor Simpson rush for 1 yard to the WAY34 (John Sikora). |
| Cwr | 3-2 | at Way34 | Connor Simpson pass complete to Zech Medved for 34 yards to the WAY0, 1ST DOWN CWR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:30. |
| | | Nick Bavaro kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Kyle Richey). |
| | | Waynesburg 35, Case Western Reserve 15 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 70 yards, TOP 04:15 |
| | | Nick Bavaro kickoff 33 yards to the WAY32, Coleman Mazur return 0 yards to the WAY32. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way32 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 02:27. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way32 | Blake Roar rush for 6 yards to the WAY38 (Pete LeMaster). |
| Way | 2-4 | at Way38 | Dave O'Brien rush for no gain to the WAY38 (Gavin Sandidge). |
| Way | 3-4 | at Way38 | Dave O'Brien pass complete to John Babos for 1 yard to the WAY39 (Andrew Banathy;Chanan Demery). |
| Way | 4-3 | at Way39 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 00:57. |
| Way | 4-3 | at Way39 | Jonathan Hager punt 40 yards to the CWR21, Dan Cronin return 15 yards to the CWR36 (Roomel Reese). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr36 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 00:47. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Cwr36 | Rob Cuda pass complete to Colin MacLeod for 5 yards to the CWR41 (Z. Sniadach). |
| Cwr | 2-5 | at Cwr41 | Rob Cuda pass incomplete to DiFrancesco. |
| Cwr | 3-5 | at Cwr41 | Rob Cuda pass incomplete to Ethan Albers (Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 4-5 | at Cwr41 | Rob Cuda pass complete to Ethan Albers for 14 yards to the WAY45, 1ST DOWN CWR, out-of-bounds. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way45 | Rob Cuda pass complete to Ethan Albers for 18 yards to the WAY27, 1ST DOWN CWR (Danny Morgan;Dontae Gibson). |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way27 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 00:04. |
| Cwr | 1-10 | at Way27 | Rob Cuda pass incomplete to Colin MacLeod. |
| Cwr | 2-10 | at Way27 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 37 yards, TOP 00:47 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Waynesburg 35, Case Western Reserve 15 |