| | | Waynesburg wins the toss, defers choice to second half. Muskies rec. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus35 | WAY ball on WAY35. |
| | | Alex Henry kickoff 48 yards to the MUS17, Alvin Taylor return 7 yards to the MUS24 (Jon. Carlier). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus24 | Shane Dotson rush for no gain to the MUS24 (JT Thompson). |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Mus24 | Shane Dotson rush for 3 yards to the MUS27 (Kyle Richey). |
| Mus | 3-7 | at Mus27 | C.J. Snider rush for 7 yards to the MUS34 (Ronnie Skinner), PENALTY MUS holding 10 yards to the MUS24. |
| Mus | 3-10 | at Mus24 | 3rd and 10. |
| Mus | 3-10 | at Mus24 | C.J. Snider rush for 11 yards to the MUS35, 1ST DOWN MUS (Ryan Harr). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus35 | Shane Dotson rush for loss of 1 yard to the MUS34 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 2-11 | at Mus34 | Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the MUS38 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 3-7 | at Mus38 | Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the MUS42 (JT Thompson). |
| Mus | 4-3 | at Mus42 | Samuel Green punt 46 yards to the WAY12, Bernie Thompson return 18 yards to the WAY30 (Luke Weber). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 18 yards, TOP 04:50 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way30 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 10:10. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way30 | Jake Forsythe rush for 2 yards to the WAY32 (Damond Goggins;Luke Weber). |
| Way | 2-8 | at Way32 | Carter Hill pass complete to Mike Ferraro for 1 yard to the WAY33. |
| Way | 3-7 | at Way33 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 12 yards to the WAY45, 1ST DOWN WAY (Mason Bates). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way45 | Carter Hill pass complete to Willie Leavell for 4 yards to the WAY49 (Alex Adams). |
| Way | 2-6 | at Way49 | Jake Forsythe rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAY48 (Darell Jones). |
| Way | 3-7 | at Way48 | Carter Hill pass complete to Zac Capan for 7 yards to the MUS45, 1ST DOWN WAY (Alex Adams). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus45 | Jake Forsythe rush for 7 yards to the MUS38 (Darell Jones;Aaron Smith). |
| Way | 2-3 | at Mus38 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Jake Danks. |
| Way | 3-3 | at Mus38 | Thomas Paulone rush for 2 yards to the MUS36 (Alex Adams). |
| Way | 4-1 | at Mus36 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 04:57. |
| Way | 4-1 | at Mus36 | Jake Forsythe rush for 12 yards to the MUS24, 1ST DOWN WAY (Tristan Heath;Mason Bates). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus24 | Carter Hill pass complete to Willie Leavell for 24 yards to the MUS0, 1ST DOWN WAY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:14. |
| | | Alex Henry kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 7, Muskingum 0 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 70 yards, TOP 06:01 |
| | | Alex Henry kickoff 57 yards to the MUS8, Alvin Taylor return 23 yards to the MUS31 (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus31 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 04:09. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus31 | C.J. Snider rush for 2 yards to the MUS33 (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 2-8 | at Mus33 | C.J. Snider rush for 17 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MUS (Stephen Holt). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus50 | Shane Dotson rush for 6 yards to the WAY44 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 2-4 | at Way44 | C.J. Snider rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAY45 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 3-5 | at Way45 | C.J. Snider rush for 1 yard to the WAY44 (Danny Morgan;John Sikora). |
| Mus | 4-4 | at Way44 | Samuel Green punt 36 yards to the WAY8, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 25 yards, TOP 03:25 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way08 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 00:44. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way08 | Jake Forsythe rush for 8 yards to the WAY16 (Damond Goggins;Mason Bates). |
| Way | 2-2 | at Way16 | Jake Forsythe rush for 2 yards to the WAY18, 1ST DOWN WAY (Luke Weber). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 10 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| | | Waynesburg 7, Muskingum 0 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way18 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way18 | Jerry Lawman rush for 2 yards to the WAY20 (Mason Bates;J.DeWitt III). |
| Way | 2-8 | at Way20 | Jerry Lawman rush for 5 yards to the WAY25 (Alex Adams). |
| Way | 3-3 | at Way25 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Mike Ferraro. |
| Way | 4-3 | at Way25 | Dominic Zappa punt 33 yards to the MUS42, fair catch by Alex Dickey. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus42 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 13:43. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus42 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 25 yards to the WAY33, 1ST DOWN MUS, out-of-bounds. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way33 | Desmond Waden rush for no gain to the WAY33 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Way33 | Desmond Waden rush for 6 yards to the WAY27 (Zach Machuga). |
| Mus | 3-4 | at Way27 | C.J. Snider sacked for loss of 13 yards to the WAY40 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 4-17 | at Way40 | PENALTY MUS delay of game 5 yards to the WAY45. |
| Mus | 4-22 | at Way45 | Samuel Green punt 22 yards to the WAY23, fair catch by Bernie Thompson. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 13 yards, TOP 02:47 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way23 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 10:56. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way23 | Jake Forsythe rush for 3 yards to the WAY26 (Nick Beany). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Way26 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 14 yards to the WAY40, 1ST DOWN WAY (Alex Adams;Tristan Heath). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way40 | Willie Leavell rush for 1 yard to the WAY41 (Jordan Lee). |
| Way | 2-9 | at Way41 | Willie Leavell rush for 6 yards to the WAY47 (Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 3-3 | at Way47 | Jake Forsythe rush for no gain to the WAY47 (Luke Weber;Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 4-3 | at Way47 | Dominic Zappa punt 33 yards to the MUS20, fair catch by Alex Dickey. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 24 yards, TOP 03:10 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus20 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 07:46. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus20 | Desmond Waden rush for 2 yards to the MUS22 (John Sikora;Adam Steiner). |
| Mus | 2-8 | at Mus22 | C.J. Snider pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 3 yards to the MUS25 (Stephen Holt). |
| Mus | 3-5 | at Mus25 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to Erik Hall (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 4-5 | at Mus25 | Samuel Green punt 20 yards to the MUS45, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus45 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 06:16. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus45 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 33 yards to the MUS12, 1ST DOWN WAY (Aaron Smith). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus12 | PENALTY WAY delay of game 5 yards to the MUS17. |
| Way | 1-15 | at Mus17 | Carter Hill pass complete to Zac Capan for 8 yards to the MUS9 (Tristan Heath). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Mus09 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 9 yards to the MUS0, 1ST DOWN WAY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:20. |
| | | Alex Henry kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Muskingum 0 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 45 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| | | Alex Henry kickoff 60 yards to the MUS5, Alex Dickey return 16 yards to the MUS21 (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus21 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 04:15. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus21 | C.J. Snider rush for 2 yards to the MUS23 (Kyle Richey). |
| Mus | 2-8 | at Mus23 | Shane Dotson rush for 8 yards to the MUS31, 1ST DOWN MUS (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus31 | Shane Dotson rush for 2 yards to the MUS33 (Josh Tolliver;Ronnie Skinner). |
| Mus | 2-8 | at Mus33 | C.J. Snider pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 16 yards to the MUS49, 1ST DOWN MUS (John Sikora). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus49 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to J.Washington. |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Mus49 | C.J. Snider rush for 14 yards to the WAY37, 1ST DOWN MUS (Stephen Holt). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way37 | C.J. Snider rush for 11 yards to the WAY26, 1ST DOWN MUS (Bryan Gary;Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way26 | C.J. Snider rush for no gain to the WAY26 (JT Thompson;Josh Tolliver). |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Way26 | Timeout Muskingum, clock 00:58. |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Way26 | C.J. Snider rush for 7 yards to the WAY19 (Bryan Gary;Kyle Richey). |
| Mus | 3-3 | at Way19 | Desmond Waden rush for 14 yards to the WAY5, 1ST DOWN MUS (John Sikora;Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 1-G | at Way05 | C.J. Snider rush for 1 yard to the WAY4 (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 2-G | at Way04 | Timeout Muskingum, clock 00:16. |
| Mus | 2-G | at Way04 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 4 yards to the WAY0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:09. |
| | | Caleb Carpenter kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Muskingum 7 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 79 yards, TOP 04:11 |
| | | Caleb Carpenter kickoff 57 yards to the WAY8, Bernie Thompson return 21 yards to the WAY29 (Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way29 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 00:04. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way29 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAY28. |
| Way | 2-11 | at Way28 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| Way | 2-11 | at Way28 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:04 |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Muskingum 7 |
| Way | 2-11 | at Way28 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Way | 2-11 | at Way28 | MUS ball on MUS35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:04 |
| | | Cody Dent kickoff 62 yards to the WAY3, Bernie Thompson return 28 yards to the WAY31 (Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way31 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 14:54. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way31 | Willie Leavell rush for loss of 4 yards to the WAY27 (J.DeWitt III). |
| Way | 2-14 | at Way27 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Willie Leavell. |
| Way | 3-14 | at Way27 | Jake Forsythe rush for 3 yards to the WAY30 (Erik Hall). |
| Way | 4-11 | at Way30 | Dominic Zappa punt 25 yards to the MUS45, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus45 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 13:24. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus45 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 38 yards to the WAY17, 1ST DOWN MUS. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way17 | C.J. Snider rush for loss of 4 yards to the WAY21 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 2-14 | at Way21 | C.J. Snider pass complete to Shane Dotson for 6 yards to the WAY15 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 3-8 | at Way15 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to Marvin Morris. |
| Mus | 4-8 | at Way15 | Caleb Carpenter field goal attempt from 32 GOOD, clock 11:29. |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Muskingum 10 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 40 yards, TOP 02:00 |
| | | Cody Dent kickoff 43 yards to the WAY22, M. Radziukinas return 14 yards to the WAY36 (D.Williams;Alex Sullivan). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way36 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 11:24. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way36 | Jake Forsythe rush for 6 yards to the WAY42 (Cody McKenzie;Tony Moore). |
| Way | 2-4 | at Way42 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Mike Ferraro. |
| Way | 3-4 | at Way42 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Bernie Thompson. |
| Way | 4-4 | at Way42 | Dominic Zappa punt 25 yards to the MUS33, fair catch by Alex Dickey. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus33 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 10:26. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus33 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete. |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Mus33 | J.Washington rush for 11 yards to the MUS44, 1ST DOWN MUS (M. Lopuchovsky). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus44 | C.J. Snider rush for 9 yards to the WAY47 (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 2-1 | at Way47 | Shane Dotson rush for 5 yards to the WAY42, 1ST DOWN MUS (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way42 | Shane Dotson rush for 8 yards to the WAY34 (Ronnie Skinner). |
| Mus | 2-2 | at Way34 | Shane Dotson rush for loss of 4 yards to the WAY38 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 3-6 | at Way38 | Marvin Morris rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAY39 (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 4-7 | at Way39 | Samuel Green punt 39 yards to the WAY0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 28 yards, TOP 03:41 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way20 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 06:45. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way20 | Willie Leavell rush for 3 yards to the WAY23 (Jordan Lee). |
| Way | 2-7 | at Way23 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Jake Danks. |
| Way | 3-7 | at Way23 | Carter Hill sacked for loss of 9 yards to the WAY14 (Jordan Lee). |
| Way | 4-16 | at Way14 | Dominic Zappa punt 30 yards to the WAY44, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:19 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way44 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 05:26. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way44 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 11 yards to the WAY33, 1ST DOWN MUS. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way33 | C.J. Snider pass complete to Marvin Morris for 4 yards to the WAY29, out-of-bounds (John Sikora). |
| Mus | 2-6 | at Way29 | Marvin Morris rush for 1 yard to the WAY28 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 3-5 | at Way28 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to J.Washington (Marvin Sampson). |
| Mus | 4-5 | at Way28 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 4 yards to the WAY24, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:15 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way24 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 03:11. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way24 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 11 yards to the WAY35, 1ST DOWN WAY, out-of-bounds, PENALTY MUS personal foul (Tristan Heath) 15 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WAY. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | 1st and 10. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way50 | Jake Forsythe rush for 6 yards to the MUS44 (Erik Hall). |
| Way | 2-4 | at Mus44 | Jerry Lawman rush for loss of 2 yards to the MUS46 (Luke Weber). |
| Way | 3-6 | at Mus46 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Danks for 19 yards to the MUS27, 1ST DOWN WAY, out-of-bounds. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus27 | Willie Leavell rush for 7 yards to the MUS20 (Alex Adams;Erik Hall). |
| Way | 2-3 | at Mus20 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Andrew English. |
| Way | 3-3 | at Mus20 | Jake Forsythe rush for loss of 1 yard to the MUS21 (Chaney Fulton;Damond Goggins). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 55 yards, TOP 03:15 |
| | | Waynesburg 14, Muskingum 10 |
| Way | 4-4 | at Mus21 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Way | 4-4 | at Mus21 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Thomas Paulone. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 55 yards, TOP 03:15 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus21 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 14:56. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus21 | C.J. Snider rush for no gain to the MUS21 (Levi Powell;JT Thompson). |
| Mus | 2-10 | at Mus21 | Shane Dotson rush for 26 yards to the MUS47, 1ST DOWN MUS (Logan McAnany). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus47 | Shane Dotson rush for loss of 3 yards to the MUS44 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Mus | 2-13 | at Mus44 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 9 yards to the WAY47, out-of-bounds. |
| Mus | 3-4 | at Way47 | C.J. Snider rush for loss of 2 yards to the WAY49 (Levi Powell). |
| Mus | 4-6 | at Way49 | Samuel Green punt 33 yards to the WAY16, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 30 yards, TOP 03:14 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way16 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 11:42. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way16 | Jerry Lawman rush for 2 yards to the WAY18 (Luke Weber). |
| Way | 2-8 | at Way18 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jerry Lawman for 2 yards to the WAY20 (Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 3-6 | at Way20 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Danks for 5 yards to the WAY25 (Mason Bates;Tyler Lancaster). |
| Way | 4-1 | at Way25 | Dominic Zappa punt 35 yards to the MUS40, Alex Dickey return 0 yards to the MUS40 (Stephen Holt). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus40 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 09:39. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus40 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 16 yards to the WAY44, 1ST DOWN MUS (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way44 | Shane Dotson rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAY45 (Kyle Richey). |
| Mus | 2-11 | at Way45 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to Bradon Hardy, PENALTY WAY pass interference (John Sikora) 7 yards to the WAY38, 1ST DOWN MUS, NO PLAY. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way38 | C.J. Snider rush for 8 yards to the WAY30, fumble forced by TEAM, fumble by C.J. Snider recovered by WAY Logan McAnany at WAY18, PENALTY MUS personal foul (Sam Lucas) 15 yards to the WAY33, 1st and 10, WAY ball on WAY33. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 42 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way33 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 08:19. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way33 | Jake Forsythe rush for 15 yards to the WAY48, 1ST DOWN WAY (Darell Jones). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way48 | Carter Hill rush for 2 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| Way | 2-8 | at Way50 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Willie Leavell. |
| Way | 3-8 | at Way50 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Jake Danks. |
| Way | 4-8 | at Way50 | Dominic Zappa punt 50 yards to the MUS0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 17 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus20 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 07:03. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus20 | Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the MUS24 (JT Thompson;Levi Powell). |
| Mus | 2-6 | at Mus24 | C.J. Snider pass complete to Wes Rataiczak for 6 yards to the MUS30, 1ST DOWN MUS (Marvin Sampson). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus30 | Shane Dotson rush for loss of 4 yards to the MUS26 (Ronnie Skinner). |
| Mus | 2-14 | at Mus26 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 8 yards to the MUS34. |
| Mus | 3-6 | at Mus34 | C.J. Snider rush for 66 yards to the WAY0, 1ST DOWN MUS, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:01. |
| | | Caleb Carpenter kick attempt good. |
| | | Muskingum 17, Waynesburg 14 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 80 yards, TOP 03:02 |
| | | Cody Dent kickoff 65 yards to the WAY0, touchback. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way25 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 04:01. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way25 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Danks for 6 yards to the WAY31 (Darell Jones). |
| Way | 2-4 | at Way31 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Forsythe for 2 yards to the WAY33 (Chaney Fulton). |
| Way | 3-2 | at Way33 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Jake Danks (Tyler Lancaster). |
| Way | 4-2 | at Way33 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 02:48. |
| Way | 4-2 | at Way33 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Mike Ferraro. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:18 |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way33 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 02:43. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Way33 | Shane Dotson rush for 3 yards to the WAY30 (Ronnie Skinner). |
| Mus | 2-7 | at Way30 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 02:36. |
| Mus | 2-7 | at Way30 | Shane Dotson rush for 1 yard to the WAY29 (Josh Tolliver). |
| Mus | 3-6 | at Way29 | Timeout Waynesburg, clock 02:31. |
| Mus | 3-6 | at Way29 | Shane Dotson rush for no gain to the WAY29 (Ronnie Skinner). |
| Mus | 4-6 | at Way29 | Timeout Muskingum, clock 01:45. |
| Mus | 4-6 | at Way29 | Shane Dotson rush for 4 yards to the WAY25, PENALTY MUS holding (Denny Ardman) 10 yards to the WAY35. |
| Mus | 4-12 | at Way35 | 4th and 12. |
| Mus | 4-12 | at Way35 | Timeout Muskingum, clock 01:38. |
| Mus | 4-12 | at Way35 | C.J. Snider pass incomplete to Marvin Morris. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:12 |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way35 | WAYNESBURG drive start at 01:31. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Way35 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Danks for 9 yards to the WAY44 (Tyler Lancaster). |
| Way | 2-1 | at Way44 | Carter Hill pass complete to Jake Danks for 8 yards to the MUS48, 1ST DOWN WAY. |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus48 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Zac Capan (D.Williams). |
| Way | 2-10 | at Mus48 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Mike Ferraro. |
| Way | 3-10 | at Mus48 | Carter Hill pass complete to Andrew English for 25 yards to the MUS23, 1ST DOWN WAY (Alex Adams). |
| Way | 1-10 | at Mus23 | Carter Hill pass incomplete to Willie Leavell. |
| Way | 2-10 | at Mus23 | Carter Hill pass complete to Bernie Thompson for 23 yards to the MUS0, 1ST DOWN WAY, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:22. |
| | | Alex Henry kick attempt good. |
| | | Waynesburg 21, Muskingum 17 |
| Way | 1-G | at Way35 | PENALTY MUS personal foul 15 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 65 yards, TOP 01:13 |
| | | Alex Henry kickoff 50 yards to the MUS0, Alex Dickey return 9 yards to the MUS9 (Bryan Gary). |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus09 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 00:18. |
| Mus | 1-10 | at Mus09 | C.J. Snider sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MUS2 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 2-17 | at Mus02 | Timeout Muskingum, clock 00:03. |
| Mus | 2-17 | at Mus02 | C.J. Snider pass complete to J.Washington for 7 yards to the MUS9 (Brandon Fedorka). |
| Mus | 3-10 | at Mus09 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:18 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Waynesburg 21, Muskingum 17 |